Eye Health Library: Dry Eye

Why Aren't Artificial Tears Fixing My Dry Eye?

Artificial tears relieve symptoms but don't treat most causes of dry eye. Learn why drops stop helping, which drops to avoid, and what to do next.

Artificial tears add moisture for a short time, but they usually don't address why the tear film is unstable. If your dry eye comes from clogged meibomian glands, inflammation, eyelid disease, or low tear production, drops alone often fall short. Using them many times a day with little lasting relief is a sign to get a full dry eye evaluation.

Key takeaways

  • Artificial tears treat symptoms, not most underlying causes.
  • Preservatives in frequently used drops can irritate the eye surface.
  • Redness relief drops are not dry eye treatment.
  • Needing drops more than about four times a day is a reason to be evaluated.

What artificial tears can and can’t do

Artificial tears are lubricating drops. They temporarily thicken and supplement the watery part of the tear film, rinse away irritants, and make the surface feel smoother. For mild, occasional dryness, that may be all you need.

But most chronic dry eye isn’t caused by a simple lack of water. The most common driver is meibomian gland dysfunction, where the oily layer that keeps tears from evaporating is deficient. Adding water-based drops to an eye that can’t hold onto its tears is like refilling a bucket with a hole in it.

Common reasons drops stop working

  • The cause is untreated. Clogged glands, blepharitis, Demodex, or eyelids that don’t close fully keep destabilizing the tear film.
  • Inflammation. Ongoing surface inflammation keeps the cycle going. Lubricants don’t treat inflammation. See inflammation and dry eye.
  • Preservatives. Some multi-dose bottles contain preservatives that can irritate the surface with frequent use.
  • The wrong type. A watery drop may not help an oil deficiency, and a thick gel may blur vision during the day.
  • Redness relief drops. Decongestant drops shrink blood vessels but don’t lubricate, and frequent use can lead to rebound redness.
  • Medications or habits. Antihistamines, some other medications, long screen sessions, and contact lens wear can outpace drops.
  • It isn’t only dry eye. Allergies, infections, and other surface conditions can mimic dry eye.

Signs it’s time for an evaluation

  • You use drops more than about four times a day.
  • Relief lasts only minutes.
  • Your vision fluctuates during the day.
  • You’ve tried several brands without improvement.
  • Contact lenses have become uncomfortable.
  • Your eyelids are red, crusty, or swollen.

What a full evaluation adds

A dry eye evaluation measures tear stability and volume, checks the surface for damage, examines the eyelids, and images the meibomian glands. Once we know what’s driving your symptoms, treatment can target it. That may include lid care and warm compresses, prescription anti-inflammatory drops, treating Demodex, punctal plugs to keep tears on the eye longer, or in-office gland treatments such as IPL.

Artificial tears often still have a role, just as one part of a plan rather than the whole plan.

This article is general education, not medical advice. Your eyes are individual, and an exam is the best way to know what is going on and what will help.

Frequently asked questions

Which artificial tears are best?

There isn't one best drop for everyone. Preservative-free drops are generally gentler for frequent use, and lipid-based drops may help when the oily layer is deficient. We can recommend a drop based on your exam.

Can I use artificial tears with contacts?

Only drops labeled for use with contact lenses should be used while lenses are in. Ask us which ones are compatible with your lens type.

Sources and further reading

  1. American Academy of Ophthalmology. What Is Dry Eye? Symptoms, Causes and Treatment.
  2. National Eye Institute. Dry Eye.
  3. Nichols KK, et al. The International Workshop on Meibomian Gland Dysfunction: Executive Summary. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science. 2011;52(4):1922-1929.
Copper View Eye Care + Aesthetics

Ready for answers about your dry eyes?

A dry eye evaluation looks for why your eyes are uncomfortable, so treatment can match the cause. Book online, or call or text and we will help you choose the right visit.